David Marshall

[Mr Shitpeas]

Retired. Best city goalie ever?

 

[Jimmytaff]

Retired. Best city goalie ever?

That seems a big call but I'd say he'd have a good shout for best City keeper of the last 50 years

 

[Mr Shitpeas]

 

[Kiffa 2.1]

If we’re discounting Dimi then I’d say so

 

[Mr Shitpeas]

If we’re discounting Dimi then I’d say so

And Ng of course

 

[NumberAde]

That seems a big call but I'd say he'd have a good shout for best City keeper of the last 50 years

I'm going to say Heaton was better. Marshall had the jersey though.

 

[stantys tattoos]

I'm going to say Heaton was better. Marshall had the jersey though.

tough choice ade 2 good keepers

 

[NumberAde]

tough choice ade 2 good keepers

The best two keepers in the division, and both were here Stants.

Marshall got the shirt though. Remember seeing Heaton at Arsenal in a Cup replay, and he was immense. We lost 4-0, it would have been double figures without him.

 

[stantys tattoos]

tom heaton has joined the england squad as a coach

Tom Heaton to join England's EURO 2024 group

The Manchester United player will travel to Germany with the Three Lions squad as a training goalkeeper

www.englandfootball.com

 

[NumberAde]

tom heaton has joined the england squad as a coach

Tom Heaton to join England's EURO 2024 group

The Manchester United player will travel to Germany with the Three Lions squad as a training goalkeeper

www.englandfootball.com

Margetson got the boot then? Good.

 

[stantys tattoos]

The best two keepers in the division, and both were here Stants.

Marshall got the shirt though. Remember seeing Heaton at Arsenal in a Cup replay, and he was immense. We lost 4-0, it would have been double figures without him.

we've been blessed with good keepers over the years.

latetly.......

 

[stantys tattoos]

Margetson got the boot then? Good.

still there ade

 

[NumberAde]

still there ade

Wanker. England and Swansea. Like he's deliberately winding me up.

 

[stantys tattoos]

Wanker. England and Swansea. Like he's deliberately winding me up.

read the link, btec dai

 

[NumberAde]

read the link, btec dai

Sorry Stants, I see links these days and expect it to be about the Hamas rapists.

 

[Jimmytaff]

I'm going to say Heaton was better. Marshall had the jersey though.

Depends how you judge it. Heaton probably better career, Marshall better at City

 

[Popeye]

Very good keeper at Championship level. Bit dodgy at times but that’s probably why he spent most of his career in the 2nd tier rather than in the PL.
As above, I think Heaton was the better of the two but the coaches obviously seen something different in training.

 

[Melvin Udal]

Very good keeper at Championship level. Bit dodgy at times but that’s probably why he spent most of his career in the 2nd tier rather than in the PL.
As above, I think Heaton was the better of the two but the coaches obviously seen something different in training.

In the showers

 

[Ponty and pop]

That seems a big call but I'd say he'd have a good shout for best City keeper of the last 50 years

Probably the best we have had.
I remember Bob Wilson as a kid I thought he was brilliant but Marshall edges it for me.
We have been fortunate with keepers over the years.

 

[Jimmytaff]

Probably the best we have had.
I remember Bob Wilson as a kid I thought he was brilliant but Marshall edges it for me.
We have been fortunate with keepers over the years.

Bob Wilson and Farquharson were the only two names that sprung to my mind as competition but you can only judge your own era and even that's hard. I was tempted to go for Gavin Ward, who did have a decent career and was good for us but at a much lower level. I was a kid then di didn't have much to compare him too

Alexander worthy of a shout too but never had the chance to sign in the Prem like Marshall did.