West Dock Public House, Cardiff c.1890
Brewer v Naish.
The Horse that panicked and ran into a pub.
For those that remember visiting the northern dock named pubs in Cardiff, there was the East Dock and the West Dock.
Remember the last landlord of the West Dock in the 1960s came from the Bridge Hotel in Bute Street. His tenure was not long.
His pub was demolished in the 1960s and stood at the head of Collingdon Road and the Bute West Dock.
In the old day’s sailors could leave their ship and walk straight into the pub - it was that convenient! Between the ship and the pub was one building, Edward England's potato warehouse.
Thomas Naish, the landlord of the West Dock Public House, Herbert Street took out a private summons against John Brewer a potato merchant.
• He alleged that a horse driven by a carter employed by Brewer, had crashed against his pub window, destroying it, breaking up seats inside the pub and causing damage to other pub property. The most expensive work was the lettering on the window, showing the name of the pub.
The carter said that he was driving the horse towards Herbert Street from Bute Street when a whistle of a Taff Vale railway engine scared the horse and he charged, pulling the cart behind him. He had tried to control the horse which nearly ran down the canal bank and he had pulled up the reins with some force, which annoyed the horse even more and it ran straight into the pub window, head first!
Whose fault was it? The Steam Engine? The Horse? The carter? Brewer the owner?
The Judge awarded Thomas Naish, the West Dock landlord £11, plus costs.
John Brewer was deemed liable for it all.